Dealing with Emissions

Cyriel de Jong wrote chapter 10 in book ‘Managing Energy Price Risk’, together with André Oosterom and Kasper Walet. This chapter focuses on dealing with emissions. Third edition, 2004.

Download directly this article

Introduction and policy context

This chapter examines the emergence of emission trading systems in response to global climate change concerns, particularly under the Kyoto Protocol. Within the European Union, a multinational emissions trading scheme was being developed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and incorporate environmental costs into economic decision-making. The system represents a shift from treating emissions as a free externality to pricing them as a measurable cost. This fundamentally changes the behavior of energy companies, especially power producers, for whom emissions become both a cost factor and a determinant of investment strategy and operational decisions.

Economic rationale for emission trading

Emission trading is based on the concept of negative externalities, where environmental damage is not reflected in market prices. By introducing tradable emission rights, policymakers aim to correct this market failure and achieve cost-efficient emission reductions. Compared to alternatives such as emission taxes or direct caps, a cap-and-trade system combines environmental certainty with economic efficiency. It ensures that a predefined emission target is met while allowing companies to minimize costs by trading allowances.

Lessons from the US Acid Rain Program

The US Acid Rain Program provides valuable insights into the functioning of emission markets. It demonstrated that such markets can become liquid and efficient, but also showed unexpected outcomes, such as lower-than-anticipated allowance prices. These results were partly driven by overinvestment in emission reduction technologies and technological progress. The program also highlighted the importance of monitoring, enforcement, and market transparency. Companies initially relied heavily on internal compliance strategies, such as investment in reduction capacity, but gradually increased participation in trading and banking of allowances.

Investment decisions and flexibility

A key focus of the chapter is how emission trading affects investment decisions. Traditional net present value (NPV) analysis is extended to include the costs and benefits of emission reductions and allowance trading. However, the authors argue that standard NPV approaches often overlook the value of flexibility. The option to delay investments, referred to as the deferral option, is particularly important under uncertain emission prices. Companies may benefit from postponing irreversible investments until market conditions become clearer, especially when price volatility is high.

Role of real options and banking

The chapter introduces real options analysis to better capture investment flexibility. Options such as deferral, abandonment, expansion, and switching provide additional value beyond traditional valuation methods. Banking of emission rights further enhances flexibility by allowing companies to shift allowances over time, effectively enabling intertemporal trading. Incorporating these elements leads to more accurate evaluation of investment opportunities and often alters optimal decisions.

Conclusion

Emission trading fundamentally reshapes energy markets by integrating environmental costs into pricing and investment decisions. The chapter concludes that companies must adopt more sophisticated valuation methods that account for uncertainty and flexibility. Real options and trading strategies play a central role in optimizing outcomes, while lessons from existing systems highlight the importance of avoiding premature investment and maintaining flexibility in uncertain markets.

If you wish to buy this book: Managing Energy Price Risk (4th edition) – Risk Books

Download MEPR Dealing with Emissions

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

By submitting this form, you agree that your details will be stored in our database and you will be informed about updates from KYOS. We will never provide your details to others, and you can unsubscribe at any time. More information on how we store your details can be found in our privacy policy.