Gas hubs jockey for position
Energy Power Risk Management published an article by Cyriel de Jong and Kasper Walet, November 2003. In ‘Gas hubs jockey for position’, the authors state that the Bunde-Oude natural gas hub on the German-Dutch border is the most likely candidate to become the Henry Hub of Europe.
Continental Europe is still far from being a mature energy market, despite the proliferation of natural gas hubs in the region. The European Commission directives passed so far – while positive steps – have not done enough to create a standard framework for trading such as that of the US or UK.
Download directly this article
Development of European gas hubs
The paper explores the early development of natural gas trading hubs in Europe, a market that, at the time, was still far from mature compared to the United States or the United Kingdom. The emergence of multiple hubs reflects the liberalisation of energy markets and the growing need for organised trading points where supply and demand can meet efficiently. Hubs are defined as locations where major pipeline connections intersect, allowing market participants to trade both physical gas and delivery rights. As trading activity increases, these hubs can evolve into more sophisticated marketplaces offering storage, processing, and financial services.
Competition between key hubs
A central theme of the article is the competition among European gas hubs to become the dominant trading center. The Bunde-Oude region on the Dutch-German border is identified as a strong candidate due to its strategic location and infrastructure. However, its development is hindered by the presence of two competing hubs, EuroHub and Hubco, which divide liquidity and slow market growth. Similarly, Zeebrugge in Belgium is the most active continental hub at the time, benefiting from high participation and infrastructure advantages, but is often seen as an extension of the UK market rather than an independent leader.
Role of market structure and regulation
The success of any gas hub depends heavily on market structure and regulatory conditions. In Germany, the dominance of a few vertically integrated companies and the absence of full liberalisation limit competition and transparency. The introduction of regulation, such as an entry-exit system and the unbundling of activities, is seen as crucial for enabling efficient trading and attracting liquidity. The paper emphasizes that without a fair and open market framework, even well-positioned hubs may fail to develop into leading trading centers.
Alternative hubs and market dynamics
Other potential hubs include the UK’s National Balancing Point (NBP) and Baumgarten in Austria. The NBP is already a mature and liquid market, giving it a significant advantage despite its geographic limitations. Baumgarten benefits from its role as a gateway for Russian gas, but its growth depends on the willingness of suppliers like Gazprom to provide sufficient volumes for short-term trading. Across all hubs, liquidity tends to concentrate in a single dominant market, suggesting that only a few hubs will ultimately succeed.
Importance of liquidity and financial markets
The development of liquid spot markets is essential for the evolution of gas trading. As liquidity increases, financial trading instruments such as futures and options can emerge, enabling broader participation from financial institutions. These instruments help manage price and basis risks and attract new market players, further enhancing efficiency. The paper concludes that transparency, liquidity, and supportive regulation are the key drivers that will determine which hubs succeed and shape the future European gas market.

Download EPRM Gas Hubs Jockey for Position
"*" indicates required fields



